Home
Reading
Searching
Subscribe
Sponsors
Statistics
Posting
Contact
Spam
Lists
Links
About
Hosting
Filtering
Features Download
Marketing
Archives
FAQ
Blog
 
Gmane

From: Manoj Srivastava <srivasta <at> debian.org>
Subject: Re: Call for vote (Re: call for seconds: on firmware)
Newsgroups: gmane.linux.debian.devel.vote
Date: Wednesday 10th December 2008 18:43:27 UTC (over 10 years ago)
Hi,

        Here is the *DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT* ballot for the GR. Please note
 the dates on the ballot; voting is not open yet.

        Please send comments to the [email protected] list.

        manoj

    General Resolution: Lenny and resolving DFSG violations;

   FIRST CALL FOR VOTES FOR THE Lenny Release General Resolution
   ===== ==== === ===== === === ===== ======= ======= ==========

Voting period starts      00:00:01 UTC on Sunday,   December 14th, 2008
Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC on Saturday, December 21st, 2008

This ballot is for a vote being conducted as required by the Debian
Constitution.  You may see the constitution at
http://www.debian.org/devel/constitution.
 For voting questions contact
[email protected]

Also, note that you can get a fresh ballot any time before the end of
the vote by sending a mail to 
   [email protected] 
with the subject "gr_lenny".


HOW TO VOTE

First, read the full text of the various proposals.

To cast a vote, it is necessary to send this ballot, with the text form
(which is embedded later in this ballot) filled out, to a dedicated
e-mail address, in a signed message, as described below. The dedicated
email address this ballot should be sent to is:

  [email protected]

The form you need to fill out is contained at the bottom of this
message, marked with two lines containing the characters
'-=-=-=-=-=-'. Do not erase anything between those lines, and do not
change the choice names.

There are 7 choices in the form, which you may rank with numbers between
1 and 7. In the brackets next to your preferred choice, place a 1.
Place a 2 in the brackets next to your next choice. Continue until you
reach your last choice.  Do not enter a number smaller than 1 or larger
than 7.

You may skip numbers, leave some choices unranked, and rank options
equally.  Unranked choices are considered equally the least desired
choices, and ranked below all ranked choices.

Make sure you have read the proposals in detail.

To vote "no, no matter what", rank "Further Discussion" as more desirable
than the unacceptable choices, or you may rank the "Further Discussion"
choice and leave choices you consider unacceptable blank.  (Note: if the
"Further Discussion" choice is unranked, then it is equal to all other
unranked choices, if any -- no special consideration is given to the
"Further Discussion" choice by the voting software).

Finally, mail the filled out ballot to: [email protected]

Don't worry about spacing of the columns or any quote characters (">") that
your reply inserts.

NOTE: The vote must be GPG signed (or PGP signed) with your key that is
in the Debian keyring. The voting software (Devotee) accepts mail that
either contains only an unmangled OpenPGP message (RFC 2440 compliant),
or a PGP/MIME mail (RFC 3156 compliant). You may, if you wish, choose to
send a signed, encrypted ballot: use the vote key appended below for
encryption.

- - -=-=-=-=-=- Don't Delete Anything Between These Lines =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
41b0a520-c6c1-4e7b-8c49-74ee85faf242
[   ] Choice 1: Reaffirm the Social Contract
[   ] Choice 2: Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]
[   ] Choice 3: Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]
[   ] Choice 4: Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG
violations [3:1]
[   ] Choice 5: Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise
[   ] Choice 6: Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]
[   ] Choice 7: Further Discussion
- - -=-=-=-=-=- Don't Delete Anything Between These Lines =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-


The actual text of the various options are as follows. Please note
that this does not include preludes, prologues, any preambles to the
resolution, post-ambles to the resolutions, abstracts, fore-words,
after-words, rationales, supporting documents, opinion polls,
arguments for and against, and any of the other important material you
will find on the mailing list archives. Please read the debian-vote
mailing list archives for details.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 1: Reaffirm the Social Contract
========= ======== === ====== ========

   1. We affirm that our Priorities are our users and the free
      software community (Social Contract #4); 
   2. We acknowledge that we promised to deliver a 100% free operating
      system (Social Contract #1); 
   3. Given that we have known for two previous releases that we have
      non-free bits in various parts of Debian, and a lot of progress
      has been made, and we are almost to the point where we can
      provide a free version of the Debian operating system, we will
      delay the release of Lenny until such point that the work to
      free the operating system is complete (to the best of our
      knowledge as of 1 November 2008). 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 2: Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]
====== == ===== ===== == ======= ==== =========== ======== =====

   1. We affirm that our Priorities are our users and the free
      software community (Social Contract #4); 
   2. We acknowledge that there is a lot of progress in the kernel
      firmware issue; most of the issues that were outstanding at the
      time of the last stable release have been sorted out. However,
      new issues in the kernel sources have cropped up fairly
      recently, and these new issues have not yet been addressed; 
   3. We assure the community that there will be no regressions in the
      progress made for freedom in the kernel distributed by Debian
      relative to the Etch release in Lenny (to the best of our
      knowledge as of 1 November 2008); 
   4. We give priority to the timely release of Lenny over sorting
      every bit out; for this reason, we will treat removal of
      sourceless firmware as a best-effort process, and deliver
      firmware as part of Debian Lenny as long as we are legally
      allowed to do so. 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 3: Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]
====== == ===== ===== == ======= ==== ==== ========== =====

   1. We affirm that our Priorities are our users and the free
      software community (Social Contract #4); 
   2. We acknowledge that there is a lot of progress in the kernel
      firmware issue; however, they are not yet finally sorted out; 
   3. We assure the community that there will be no regressions in the
      progress made for freedom in the kernel distributed by Debian
      relative to the Etch release in Lenny (to the best of our
      knowledge as of 1 November 2008); 
   4. We give priority to the timely release of Lenny over sorting
      every bit out; for this reason, we will treat removal of
      sourceless firmware as a best-effort process. 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 4: Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations
[3:1]
====== == ======= === ======= ==== == ====== ===== ======== ==== ==========
====

   1. Debian's priorities are our users and free software. We don't
      trade them against each other. However, while getting a release
      out of the door, decisions need to be made about how to get a
      rock-stable release of the high quality Debian is known for,
      release more or less on time, and to minimize the usage of
      problematic software. We acknowledge that there is more than
      just one minefield our core developers and the release team are
      working on.
   2. We as Developers at large continue to trust our release team to
      follow all these goals, and therefore encourage them to continue
      making case-by-case decisions as they consider fit, and if
      necessary we authorize these decisions.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 5: Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise

   1. We affirm that our Priorities are our users and the free
      software community (Social Contract #4); 
   2. We acknowledge that there is a lot of progress in the kernel
      firmware issue; most of the issues that were outstanding at the
      time of the last stable release have been sorted out. However,
      new issues in the kernel sources have cropped up fairly
      recently, and these new issues have not yet been addressed; 
   3. We assure the community that there will be no regressions in the
      progress made for freedom in the kernel distributed by Debian
      relative to the Etch release in Lenny (to the best of our
      knowledge as of 1 November 2008); 
   4. We give priority to the timely release of Lenny over sorting
      every bit out; for this reason, we will treat removal of
      sourceless firmware as a best-effort process, and deliver
      firmware as part of Debian Lenny as long as we are legally
      allowed to do so, and the firmware is distributed upstream under
      a license that complies with the DFSG. 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Choice 6: Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]

Firmware is data such as microcode or lookup tables that is loaded
into hardware components in order to make the component function
properly. It is not code that is run on the host CPU. 

Unfortunately such firmware often is distributed as so-called blobs,
with no source or further documentation that lets us learn how it
works or interacts with the hardware in question. By excluding such
firmware from Debian we exclude users that require such devices from
installing our operating system, or make it unnecessarily hard for
them. 

   1. firmware in Debian does not have to come with source. While we
      do prefer firmware that comes with source and documentation we
      will not require it, 
   2. we however do require all other freedoms that the DFSG mandate
      from components of our operating system, and 
   3. such firmware can and should be part of our official
      installation media. 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The options choice 2, choice 3, choice 4, and choice 6 supersede
foundation documents, temporarily or permanently, and thus need a 3:1
majority. The options choice 1 and choice 5) require a simple majority
to pass.

The responses to a valid vote shall be signed by the vote key created
for this vote. The public key for the vote, signed by the Project
secretary, is appended below.

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.9 (GNU/Linux)
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=n/Xz
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----


-- 
"Elvis is my copilot." Cal Keegan
Manoj Srivastava  <http://www.debian.org/~srivasta/>
 
1024D/BF24424C print 4966 F272 D093 B493 410B  924B 21BA DABB BF24 424C
 
CD: 11ms