Seems I spoke a little to early on some of the points below (see Joe's
observations later in this thread)
The project is generally doing very well, but learning to play nice with
those not fully aligned to "the one true vision" is Spongebob that needs
Sent from my mobile device, please forgive errors and brevity.
On Mar 13, 2012 5:36 PM, "Ross Gardler" wrote:
> On 13 March 2012 17:17, Dave Fisher wrote:
> >> The Apache OpenOffice project is still in incubation and has not yet
requested graduation to a TLP.
> > A release is a prerequisite to graduation. Once a release has been made
graduation is next on the agenda. Our mentors can correct me if I am wrong,
but we have likely met all of the other requirements.
> Speaking as just one mentor I believe the PPMC is now functioning as a
> healthy Apache PMC. Specifically:
> - the diversity requirement of the project has been met (in fact this
> was the case on day one)
> - all discussions relating to project strategy now take place on the
> public mailing lists
> - the voice of the lone contributor is as loud as the voice of any
> other contributor
> - decisions are being taken by those who are ready, willing and able
> to implement them
> - the community is rewarding those who earn merit with committership
> in the project
> - participants are finding their natural place within the community
> (this includes coders, testers, technical writers, forum admins,
> translators and many more)
> - the community is learning to respect and reward non-code contributions
> - there is evidence of cross-project collaboration both into and out of
> - AOO project members are appearing in the appropriate places around
> the ASF to ensure full engagement with the foundation
> - mentors very rarely interject, unless specifically called upon
> - community members are learning not to feed trolls
> In summary, yes I think the AOO project is well on its way to
> graduation. A release is a pre-requisite to graduation as that is the
> point at which the ASF is able to assert that the code is fully
> license compliant. Once the first release is complete I imagine
> graduation will not be far behind.
> I look forward to seeing AOO code allowing the further adoption of ODF
> alongside other great ODF related projects.